FB pixel

Apple wins US biometric privacy case on appeal

On-device data does not trigger BIPA requirements
Apple wins US biometric privacy case on appeal
 

In a biometrics-bound lawsuit decision more noteworthy for the name of its defendant than precedent, Apple has prevailed in a state of Illinois Biometrics Information Privacy Act case.

A state appellate court just before Christmas said that Apple does not violate BIPA by offering owners of its mobile devices the ability to unlock the operating system using their fingerprint or face.

The case was brought by David Barnett, Ethel Burr and Michael Henderson in Cook County Circuit Court. It was dismissed in January 2022 and appealed, according to legal news publication Cook County (Ill.) Record.

The matter could still be heard by the state supreme court. There also is an outside chance that a case can be made that software updates by Apple confer some ownership or control. This was not decided here.

It is not a shocking appellate decision and likely will have zero impact on other BIPA cases in the works. If anything, the decision shows businesses how to comply with the law and still legally sell biometric features and services.

Apple never collected, stored or managed the data collected by Touch ID and Face ID, functions that protect mobile Apple products from illicit access. Device owners do the scanning (or they can choose to use other access-control features) and the biometric data is stored nowhere but on their device.

Apple has no role in how the biometrics are managed, including when they are deleted.

The case could allow biometric technology providers like FaceTec, which provides algorithms to clients to process data on their own servers, to argue that they are not subject to BIPA’s requirements. The ruling could also protect on-device implementations such as those based on FIDO.

In every successful BIPA case to date, one or more companies required a person to be biometrically scanned, stored the data, used it for profit, managed the data (including sharing and/or selling it) or all of the above. They did not, however, get express permission to scan and manage or clearly state their intensions for the information or their policies for managing the data.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

Biometrics take on new roles as trust and security demands grow

Biometrics are being asked to do more than establish identity. From proving presence in remote transactions to estimating age without…

 

America is building an online ID system by lawsuit

By Raj Ananthanpillai, CEO, Trua Meta has made roughly $5.3 billion of its $18 billion settlement with state and territorial…

 

Listen: C. Maxine Most puts 25 years of biometrics predictions to the test

This year, identity veteran and biometrics market strategy guru C. Maxine Most is celebrating 25 years of her company Acuity…

 

Google proposes using digital credentials for secure account recovery

Google is developing an account recovery method using digital identity credentials to address security weaknesses in traditional recovery methods when…

 

45 attorneys general back KOSA as age verification question remains open

Forty-five state and territorial attorneys general back legislation that stops short of mandating age checks but calls for a federal…

 

Australia’s High Court weighs free speech challenge to social media age law

Australia’s social media minimum age law is facing a constitutional challenge in the High Court this week, with Reddit and…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Market Intelligence

Biometric Update Podcast

Featured Company

Top Stories This Week

White Papers

Latest Webinars

Biometrics Industry Events