FB pixel

San Francisco police hit with lawsuit over facial recognition use

San Francisco police hit with lawsuit over facial recognition use
 

In 2019, San Francisco became the first city in the U.S. to ban facial recognition technology, forcing the police and other agencies to seek approvals for surveillance technology. A new lawsuit from a non-profit group argues, however, that the city’s police have repeatedly flouted the ban and failed to submit proper documentation related to surveillance technologies.

The San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) has already come under scrutiny after a May report accused it of asking neighboring forces to search facial recognition database for them. The police admitted to circumventing the ban six times, blaming the majority of violations on two officers.

In its lawsuit, advocacy group Secure Justice says that the problem is more widespread than the SFPD admits. The organization says that the unlawful use of facial recognition puts the legitimacy of investigations prosecuted by the District Attorney in question and could lead to reviews.

Aside from violating the ban, the city’s police also stand accused of withholding documentation such as annual reports and use policies. According to the Surveillance Technology Ordinance, each San Francisco department possessing pre-existing equipment must submit an inventory, impact policy and use policy of its surveillance technologies. The SFPD has refused to submit 42 use policies for four years, Secure Justice says.

The organization’s Executive Director Brian Hofer called for an investigation into SDPD’s use of facial recognition, citing cases of false arrests and wrongful incarceration throughout the country and SFPD’s “lengthy and troubling history of racist policing practices. He added that San Francisco has at least 60 surveillance ordinance violations.

“I helped draft the ordinance,” he told the San Francisco Standard. “and have bent over backward ever since trying to get SFPD to comply, but they’ve ignored every single right-to-cure letter.”

The city, however, has been attempting to carve out exemptions in the surveillance law. The latest was initiated by San Francisco’s Mayor London Breed and passed by voters in March.

Breed’s Proposition E relaxed some of the standards in the law, allowing police departments to acquire surveillance equipment and then ask for approval within one year. The regulation also empowers SFPD to install CCTV cameras and deploy drones without oversight from the Board of Supervisors or Police Commission.

Related Posts

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

Montreal police seek 96 surveillance cameras compatible with Genetec systems

Montreal police (SPVM) are inviting bids to supply 66 standard surveillance cameras and 30 automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras….

 

Big Tech says Australia’s Duty of Care Bill gives regulators too much control

It is hardly a secret that the companies running massive social media platforms do not like regulation. Amid assurances that…

 

European Commission hits pause on national social media age check rules

Having established the urgency of introducing laws to restrict children’s use of social media, the European Commission is telling member…

 

Envoc completes pivot to custom biometric verification with FaceLock pilot program

When Envoc launched FaceLock earlier this year, it marked a new direction for one of the pioneering companies in the…

 

Kosovo launches national digital ID wallet, e-signatures ahead of EUDI alignment

Kosovo has launched a national electronic identity platform, digital wallet and electronic signature service, allowing citizens to verify their identities…

 

UK plan to use LFR for immigration control tests limit of proportionality

The revelation that the UK government plans to use live facial recognition technology for “general immigration enforcement” raises foundational questions…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Market Intelligence

Biometric Update Podcast

Featured Company

Top Stories This Week

White Papers

Latest Webinars

Biometrics Industry Events