FB pixel

Facebook says Illinois biometrics privacy law violates constitution

| Justin Lee
Categories Biometrics News  |  Facial Recognition
 

Facebook Inc. says an Illinois biometrics law that prevents interstate-sharing of facial recognition data violates the U.S. Constitution ( In re Facebook Biometric Info. Privacy Litig. , N.D. Cal., No. 15-cv-03747, answer, 11/11/16 ), according to a report by Bloomberg BNA.

Aside from Illinois, Texas and Connecticut are the only other states that have biometrics laws. Despite this, several consumer-facing companies are trying to monetize or store and analyze biometric data.

In August, three class actions against Facebook over allegations that the company’s ‘tag suggestion’ feature violates users’ privacy rights, were moved from Chicago’s federal courts to San Francisco’s.

The lawsuits stemmed from consumers claims that the company used its tag suggestions feature to cover up its use of proprietary facial recognition software to collect “unique biometric identifiers” without their consent.

On November 11, Facebook responded to the plaintiffs’ amended complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California by calling the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) ‘unconstitutional’.

Facebook said that the BIPA infringes on a constitutional protection under the commerce clause, which restricts a state’s ability to pass legislation that would improperly strain or discriminate against interstate commerce.

The social media giant said that preventing it from using biometric analysis software to search images uploaded by Illinois users places limitations on its use of data in commerce.

In addition to this defense, Facebook cited 22 other affirmative defenses to the consumer claims before the federal court, including one that said that plaintiffs and putative class “consented to and, in some cases, participated in the uploading and ‘tagging’ of photographs of which they now complain.”

BIPA, 740 Ill. Comp. Stat. § 14/15 states that no private entity may collect an individual’s “biometric identifier or biometric information” unless the person in writing that the information is being stored and “the specific purpose and length of term” of use, then receives written consent from the person to use said data.

Last month, both Facebook and Google stated that collecting facial biometrics data isn’t against the law, even without the user’s consent.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

Biometric Update Podcast digs into deepfakes with Pindrop CEO

Deepfakes are one of the biggest issues of our age. But while video deepfakes get the most attention, audio deepfakes…

 

Know your geography for successful digital ID adoption: Trinsic

A big year for digital identity issuance, adoption and regulation has widened the opportunities for businesses around the world to…

 

UK’s digital ID trust problem now between business and government

It used to be that the UK public’s trust in the government was a barrier to the establishment of a…

 

Super-recognizers can’t help with deepfakes, but deepfakes can help with algorithms

Deepfake faces are beyond even the ability of super-recognizers to identify consistently, with some sobering implications, but also a few…

 

Age assurance regulations push sites to weigh risks and explore options for compliance

Online age assurance laws have taken effect in certain jurisdictions, prompting platforms to look carefully at what they’re liable for…

 

The future of DARPA’s quantum benchmarking initiative

DARPA started the Quantum Benchmarking Initiative (QBI) in July 2024 to expand hardware capabilities and accelerate research. In April 2025,…

Comments

20 Replies to “Facebook says Illinois biometrics privacy law violates constitution”

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Continue Reading

Market Analysis

Most Viewed This Week

Featured Company

Learn More

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events