FB pixel

Scholars propose unified global regulations on facial recognition

Scholars propose unified global regulations on facial recognition

Four professors from MIT, Harvard, and Oxford propose in an article published on voxdev.org that facial recognition, without global trade regulation, could pose a threat to democracy around the world and help entrench autocratic regimes.

The article was authored by professors Martin Beraja of MIT, David Yang of Harvard University, and Noam Yuchtman of All Souls College, Oxford, along with Andrew Kao, Ph.D. student of economics at Harvard.

In their article, the scholars argue that global trade, including its influence from leading AI innovators, has played a crucial role in fostering democracy worldwide. They quote former U.S. President George H.W. Bush, who remarked: “No nation on Earth has discovered a way to import the world’s goods and services while stopping foreign ideas at the border.” However, they also caution that while trade can bring democratic ideas, it can also promote non-democratic ideologies. The professors express concern about the influence of non-democratic countries, like China, on developing nations with significant trade and investment ties. These relationships raise concerns about potential drifts from democratic ideals.

To gain insight into the facial recognition trade, the authors analyzed 1,636 deals from 36 exporting countries to 136 importing countries. Based on this data, they drew several conclusions.

First, they note that China has become a world leader in both AI and facial recognition. As a result, companies in the industry often receive access to the country’s large-scale government datasets. This has given the nation an advantage in facial recognition AI, which is evidenced by the fact that China exports to roughly twice as many countries as the U.S. and has about 10 percent more trade deals.

Additionally, they find that autocracies and weak democracies tend to import facial recognition from China rather than the U.S., especially in years marked by domestic unrest. Chinese surveillance AI imported by autocracies and weak democracies during these episodes correlates with deteriorating election fairness and entrenched non-democratic regimes.

In conclusion, the researchers believe that if the AI technology trade with developing countries remains unchecked, it could lead to negative political repercussions and loss of freedom for citizens in autocratic and developing nations. They recommend that AI regulations be crafted similarly to other currently regulated goods that have the potential for harmful impacts.

An analysis published by the Brooking Institution earlier this year drew similar conclusions about the market advantage China has in selling facial recognition to autocratic governments.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News


UK gov’t introduces new digital identity verification services bill

The UK government has announced a coming identity verification services bill that will support digital ID products and services from…


EES launch postponed to November, EU’s biometric border app may still not be ready

A smartphone app designed to streamline queues for the EU’s upcoming border checks will not be available in time for…


US government transitions Veteran’s Affairs, IRS to Login.gov or ID.me

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) says it will implement a more streamlined login process for veterans to access…


Data breach raises questions about Fractal ID’s decentralized identity architecture

A data breach at decentralized digital identity verification provider Fractal ID has exposed the ID documents and facial images of…


Physical IDs no longer mandatory in Azerbaijan, where 65% use digital identity

Physical and digital IDs have reached parity in Azerbaijan, where the government has announced that identity information provided through the…


Recfaces argues biometric data privacy rule carries Olympics security risk

RecFaces is calling for facial recognition technology (FRT) to be used as a key security measure to protect critical infrastructure…


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Read This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events