FB pixel

Oxfam weighs use of biometrics for humanitarian aid in new report

 

The recent Rohingya crisis response in Bangladesh illustrates the polarizing nature of a debate over the value of using biometrics to register people to receive humanitarian aid, according to an article by ICT in Programme Humanitarian Adviser Anna Kondakhchyan, published ahead of the release of an Oxfam report on the subject.

Coordinating aid distribution for the estimated 688,000 people displaced by the crisis has been an immense and complex effort, facilitated by biometric systems. The sensitive data collected could be used against those the programs are intended to help, however, should their persecutors acquire it, according to the article.

Oxfam put a self-imposed moratorium on biometric use into place in 2015, and began a research project in November, in collaboration with non-profit social change support organization The Engine Room, to assess whether or not to begin using the technology. The research involved interviews with stakeholders from the development sector, and biometrics industry experts and practitioners, as well as debate among the “Responsible Data” community, according to Kondakhchyan.

Oxfam initiated the research in response to the changing context around biometrics in the humanitarian sector. That changing context includes more widespread deployment of the technology, increased pressure from international donors use biometrics to demonstrate the effectiveness of programs, and a preference to distribute cash, instead of food and other essentials, to people in emergencies. These increasing pressures may not be helping the humanitarian efforts, or resulting in effective deployments of biometric technology, the report suggests.

“The report argues that amid pushes for innovation, the humanitarian sector has been home to ‘experimental’ uses of technology for technologies’ sake,” Kondakhchyan writes. “Biometrics fall in this category.”

Interviews suggest that fraud is perceived as a problem by some stakeholders, but those stakeholders were not able to quantify its extent. According to the report, “there has been no effort on the part of key user-organisations to compare the cost of instituting biometrics systems with the cost of fraud to the organisations.”

The report also considers the risk of exclusion from using biometrics, such as if people have physical or cultural reasons for being unable or reluctant to share biometric data.

Traditional methods of distributing aid to refugees can result in losses of up to 20 percent, according to an announcement earlier this year by IFC and IrisGuard of expanded use of biometrics to increase financial inclusion of Syrian refugees in Jordan.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

Streamlining airport passenger processing in Fiji and Sri Lanka

Aviation continues its digital transformation with new deals in Fiji and Sri Lanka, while airlines and technology companies continue innovating….

 

Women in Identity research sheds light on cost of ID exclusion

Identity exclusion is costing businesses money. The same problem is causing misery among real people, and in some cases preventing…

 

Sumsub reveals 300% increase in identity document fraud

Sumsub has released its Q1 2025 identity fraud trends based on its internal data and it shows a surge in…

 

Identity issuer registries can strengthen VCs for LERs: reports

A year into a research collaboration, the Digital Credentials Consortium (DCC) and Credential Engine have published a pair of reports…

 

Louisiana sees age assurance legislation battle between Big Social, Big App Store

In Louisiana, age verification legislation finds itself stirred up like a spicy gumbo. Bills regarding age assurance for adult content…

 

Inclusion must be the foundation of digital ID systems: Nordregio report

There is very high digital ID adoption in Greenland, Faroe Islands, and Åland, but these nations still face major hindrances…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Biometric Market Analysis

Most Viewed This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events