FB pixel

AI skeptics to lawmakers: Resist the urge to solve AI bias with more tech

Categories Biometric R&D  |  Biometrics News  |  Trade Notes
AI skeptics to lawmakers: Resist the urge to solve AI bias with more tech
 

European privacy advocates think it is a mistake for governments to believe more technology can make AI fair to all of the humans it serves. But if policymakers insist on that viewpoint, an alliance of AI skeptics has some recommendations.

The group, called European Digital Rights, or EDRi, has published a report based on the premise that debiasing AI algorithms and datasets (such as those in facial recognition systems) only further consolidates governance in the hands of technology companies.

Government leaders, according to the report, “must tackle the root causes of the power imbalances caused by the pervasive use of AI systems.”

Debiasing is an overly simplistic proposal, according to EDRi’s report, called “Beyond Debiasing: Regulating AI and its Inequalities.”

It means using technical design to solve complex technical problems finely integrated with societal dynamics. And it is the “primary means of addressing discrimination AI” in recent European Union policies.

Also troubling, debiasing is typically carried out by the people and processes that created biased programs to begin with.

An increasing amount of thought is going into how AI can be both effective and ethical, and not all of it involves debiasing.

The U.S. Government Accountability Office has created four principles of its own, for instance. And the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology also have opined on managing AI bias. This is not to say that either sets of ideas has gained much transaction.

The report’s authors make the case that more and better-informed public policy needs to take a greater share of control over AI. EDRi is a two-decade-old collection of subject-matter experts, non-governmental organizations, policy advocates and advocates.

Several recommendations are offered to lawmakers who likely will continue to pursue debiasing solutions for biometric systems and others.

Most of them require leaders to become well-informed on holding the technology industry responsible for removing bias — and to stay informed indefinitely.

For example, EDRi says governments have to clearly define societal problems related to AI, issue solution criteria, create guidance on known technology limitations and fund ongoing interdisciplinary research.

The guidelines also essentially call for insulating legislators and regulators from the powerful lobbying campaigns of companies that have revenue reserves beyond anything ever seen in the history of commerce.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

Biometric Update Podcast digs into deepfakes with Pindrop CEO

Deepfakes are one of the biggest issues of our age. But while video deepfakes get the most attention, audio deepfakes…

 

Know your geography for successful digital ID adoption: Trinsic

A big year for digital identity issuance, adoption and regulation has widened the opportunities for businesses around the world to…

 

UK’s digital ID trust problem now between business and government

It used to be that the UK public’s trust in the government was a barrier to the establishment of a…

 

Super-recognizers can’t help with deepfakes, but deepfakes can help with algorithms

Deepfake faces are beyond even the ability of super-recognizers to identify consistently, with some sobering implications, but also a few…

 

Age assurance regulations push sites to weigh risks and explore options for compliance

Online age assurance laws have taken effect in certain jurisdictions, prompting platforms to look carefully at what they’re liable for…

 

The future of DARPA’s quantum benchmarking initiative

DARPA started the Quantum Benchmarking Initiative (QBI) in July 2024 to expand hardware capabilities and accelerate research. In April 2025,…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Market Analysis

Most Viewed This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events