FB pixel

No end seen for parade of biometric privacy court cases as Maine bill advances

No end seen for parade of biometric privacy court cases as Maine bill advances

Maybe businesses that are collecting biometric data like it is sand on a public beach think privacy lawsuits are just the cost of doing business.

Given the court costs (and potential reputation damage) resulting from even a successful defense of biometrics cases, it is hard to understand why the private sector cannot lobby its way to coherent digital privacy laws.

March is a good month to consider this.

Legislators in the state of Maine, not what anyone would think of as a high-regulation environment, are considering a bill that would set consent and retention rules, and ban sales of biometric data.

And related lawsuit news is plentiful.

To start: Jordan Stein continues her fight with computer-vision software maker Clarifai.

Last year, she claimed in court that Clarifai used images from dating site OKCupid to improve Clarifai’s facial recognition products. Stein, an Illinois resident, said Clarifai broke the state’s Biometric Information Privacy Act.

A judge dismissed the case on the grounds of personal jurisdiction, according to a report by law firm Blank Rome.

Stein filed a new case against Clarifai last week.

The first suit did not worry potential investors overly much. Clarifai closed a $60 million series C round led by New Enterprise Associates. Also participating: Menlo Ventures, Union Square Ventures, Lux Capital, LDV Capital, NYU Innovation Venture Fund and others.

Tesla is also being sued under Illinois’ BIPA, for allegedly violating the biometric data privacy law with the driver monitoring in-cabin camera that is part of its autopilot and self-driving systems.

The full self-driving system, which uses face biometrics and eye-tracking to make sure drivers are paying attention to the road, according to the complaint, is a paid add-on feature for Tesla Model 3s and Model Ys. Plaintiff Peter Platt alleges Tesla violated BIPA’s informed consent, data retention schedule and storage disclosure rules, and used his data to train its machine learning models.

This follows, in just three weeks ending March 4, 14 BIPA-related biometric privacy cases filed in Illinois, including the following from the Cook County Record:

Tameka Little vs. Altitude Health Services and Pamela Readdy vs. Kindred THC Chicago. Altitude allegedly collected fingerprints from employees as they clocked in. Kindred THC also collected employee fingerprint biometrics, but from a scanner securing a product-dispensing machine.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News


New international standard covers forensic biometrics in lab and field environments

A lunch talk by the European Association for Biometrics (EAB) untangles the forthcoming Forensic Sciences standard ISO/IEC 21043, in particular its…


Retail biometrics’ rising tide lifts startup to €1.5M funding round

Lithuania-based autonomous retail startup Pixevia has raised €1.5 million (US$1.6 million), and plans to bring its technology to new venues…


Humane AI reportedly looking for a buyer for its biometric wearable business

mane AI is reportedly in search of a potential buyer for its business, as per a report by Bloomberg. The…


With AI tools and crypto aiding financial fraud, cops and industry gear up for a fight

The fraudulent practice of “pig butchering” continues to be a major concern in financial fraud, as highlighted in a recent…


ID R&D patents voice biometrics and spoof detection to protect smart devices

ID R&D has been granted a patent for integrated voice biometrics and spoof detection for keywords and short requests used…


Worldcoin ordered to stop operating in Hong Kong

Hong Kong’s privacy office has announced the results of its investigation into Worldcoin, and found that the iris biometrics project…


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Read This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events