FB pixel

Ryder Review calls for biometrics regulation through new, comprehensive legislation

Ryder Review calls for biometrics regulation through new, comprehensive legislation
 

Legislation is urgently needed to govern the use of biometrics, according to the widely-anticipated ‘Ryder Review’ from the Ada Lovelace Institute, the culmination of the organization’s three years of research into the challenges and potential harms brought on by use of the technology.

The Ryder Review is an independent legal review 221 pages long, and addresses the use of biometric technology and risks associated with it in England and Wales. The policy environment was formed by the passage of laws in 2001 that allowed for the collection and retention of biometric data by law enforcement, according to the report, in what it called “a wrong turn.”

The subsequent rush to build up databases of fingerprint and DNA biometrics to aid in criminal investigations was only slowed by a legal challenge filed with the European Court of Human Rights seven years later. According to the review, appropriate governance measures remain an ongoing attempted balancing act.

Remedying this situation will take a concerted legislative push, according to Ryder, a barrister at Matrix Chambers.

“Overall, we contend that if biometric technologies are to be used, they must be governed by a legal framework and a regulatory approach that align their use with the expressed needs of people and society,” writes Ada Lovelace Institute Senior Policy Advisor Madeleine Chang in a summary of the report.

Ryder makes 10 recommendations, starting with the passage of “new, primary legislation,” as well as a new regulatory body that would publish a register of biometrics deployments in the public sector. The regulator should assess both the effectiveness of biometric technologies and the proportionality of implementations in their proposed contexts.

A moratorium should be enacted for one-to-many identification biometrics in public spaces and public sector categorization, at least “until comprehensive legislation is passed,” the review says.

Ryder recommends extending the scope of legislation to include classification, as well as identification, and also that the statutory framework should require codes of practice for specific sectors or technologies, including a legally-binding code of practice for live facial recognition. A national biometrics ethics board should be established, and its advice published. Finally, further consideration is needed for private biometrics use, according to Ryder.

The Review delves into the EU’s AI draft regulation and, elsewhere, presents the views, sometimes aligned, sometimes opposed, of stakeholders from civil society, government, law enforcement and industry.

Responses from these and other stakeholders are already beginning. The Ryder Review promises to be a topic of significant discussion within the biometrics community.

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

India’s gig-economy startups need Aadhaar verification, biometrics providers can help

Indian start-ups in food delivery, ecommerce and ride-hailing are lining up to seek government approval for gig-worker identity verification. Industry…

 

BioID biometric liveness detection 99.7% successful in certification refresh

BioID’s biometric liveness detection has passed a test to refresh its standards compliance confirmation with flying colors, the company has…

 

World Bank highlights Pakistan’s progress on digital infrastructure, inclusive ID

As Pakistan transitions to a more digital economy, access, infrastructure, and inclusion remain major challenges. The World Bank’s Pakistan Development…

 

Irish online safety regulator promises to prosecute noncompliance on age checks

There has been more noise about the UK’s online safety codes, but Ireland’s new Online Safety Code also comes into…

 

Raonsecure to develop professional credential digital ID as Korea targets AI dominance

Raonsecure has signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Korea Artificial Intelligence Association and the Korea Digital Certification Association…

 

NextG lands $10M ID cards, passport contracts extension with Malaysian govt

Malaysia’s Ministry of Home Affairs has extended four existing contracts it has with partner NextG, known formerly as Datasonic Group…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Biometric Market Analysis

Most Viewed This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events