FB pixel

Porn sites try different tacks to wriggle out of US age assurance obligation

From court challenges to defanging amendments to turning off access
Categories Age Assurance  |  Biometrics News
Porn sites try different tacks to wriggle out of US age assurance obligation
 

The most popular network of pornography sites on the internet is blocking access by users in five more states as the push and pull between online age verification advocates and pornographers widens.

Pornhub and its affiliated websites will block users from Indiana, Idaho, Kansas, Kentucky, and Nebraska over age assurance requirements, citing concern for the privacy of their users, The Verge reports. The sites have already been blocked in seven other states.

The states require users to upload ID documents or use a third-party age assurance provider using facial age estimation, but The Verge follows Pornhub in skipping over the latter option. Third-party providers could use biometric facial age estimation to gain reasonable assurance of users’ ages without storing their personal information.

Enter the courts

Pornography and other digital platforms have an ally in a federal U.S. judge who ruled on Monday that Mississippi’s age verification law represents an unconstitutional limit on access to online speech, The Washington Post reports.

Mississippi’s law is supposed to protect children from grooming by online predators, but has been criticized for being overly broad, leading to a lawsuit by NetChoice.

State Attorney General Lynn Fitch argued that the bill limited only “non-expressive conduct,” but U.S. District Judge Sul Ozerden rejected that interpretation.

Texas will have to defend its HB 1181 to the U.S. Supreme Court, which has decided to take on a challenge from a “Free Speech Coalition” on constitutional grounds.

Law360 reports that the Supreme Court has already declined to stay an appeals court decision which keeps the law in place pending the outcome of the legal challenge.

Can’t someone else do it?

Meanwhile in California, the Age Verification Provider’s Association (AVPA) expects the State Senate Judiciary Committee to accept an amendment to the state’s age verification law as soon as Tuesday which the advocacy group says would render the law meaningless.

AB 3080 passed the state assembly unanimously, but now an amendment from the pornography industry that limits adult sites’ obligations to blocking “users designated as minors by the operating system of the device.” Since designating the legal age status of users is not a central or even peripheral function of operating systems, the AVPA argues in LinkedIn post that the amendment would shift obligation for performing age verification to “no legal entity.”

An editorial in Cybernews suggests that device-based age verification could potentially work, but carries several security risks of its own.

Related Posts

Article Topics

 |   |   |   |   |   |   |   | 

Latest Biometrics News

 

World Economic Forum looks to get a GRIP on global regulatory environment

A new piece written by the World Economic Forum (WEF)’s head of digital inclusion, Kelly Ommundsen, looks at the gap…

 

Respected legal authority frames age assurance legislation as segregation, suppression

Language plays a fundamental role in how concepts and technologies are introduced into and evolve alongside society. The debate over…

 

New high scores in fingerprint biometrics accuracy for Dermalog, ROC, Innovatrics

New algorithms submitted to the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology for its Proprietary Fingerprint Template (PFT) Evaluation have…

 

Australia’s safety code for search tools takes effect, with age verification rules

Like its counterparts in the EU and UK, Australia’s digital regulator is beginning to formalize its online safety codes. The…

 

Age verification coming to major video game mod site in EU, UK

Want to make sweet love to that frost giant who lives in the fjord? You may have to prove your…

 

Ecuador upgrades border ID verification with Regula forensic devices

Ecuador is upgrading its border identity verification systems by deploying a range of Regula’s ID document examination devices. The deployment…

Comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Biometric Market Analysis

Most Viewed This Week

Featured Company

Biometrics Insight, Opinion

Digital ID In-Depth

Biometrics White Papers

Biometrics Events